Tuneup Didn't Defrag Hard Drive

12-27-2007

After running Tuneup it stated that 'because of the High volume of
fragmentation defragmentation
was scheduled for a later tuneup' or something to that effect. When I run an
analysis with Windows
Defrag it tells me my disk is in good order and defragentation is not
needed.
Why the big difference in the analysis??

James

12-27-2007

"JamesJ" <jjy@xxxxxx_darwin.net> wrote:

	Quote:
	>After running Tuneup it stated that 'because of the High volume of >fragmentation defragmentation >was scheduled for a later tuneup' or something to that effect. When I run an >analysis with Windows >Defrag it tells me my disk is in good order and defragentation is not >needed. >Why the big difference in the analysis?? > >James

It's not something I'd worry about. Windows Defrag when run from Start Menu will
check first and then proceed if it deems defrag is needed. When OneCare runs
defrag, it executes it in a mode that doesn't check, it just runs. When it has
run for a long time (used to be 10 minutes, but this has been extended) it will
stop and you'll get that report. It should eventually complete without the
message if you run Tune-up fairly regularly and don't have an excessive number
of large files getting fragmented on the disk.
-steve
--
Stephen Boots sboots@xxxxxx
Microsoft MVP - Windows Live
Windows Live OneCare Forum Moderator
http://forums.microsoft.com/windowso....aspx?siteid=2

01-12-2008

In other words, it's a piece of software not well designed?
Joe

"StephenB" <sboots@xxxxxx> wrote in message
news:fni8n3d7jrhdrq0b6c42v3u0f31lra6a1t@xxxxxx

Quote:

> "JamesJ" <jjy@xxxxxx_darwin.net> wrote:
>

	Quote:
	>>After running Tuneup it stated that 'because of the High volume of >>fragmentation defragmentation >>was scheduled for a later tuneup' or something to that effect. When I run >>an >>analysis with Windows >>Defrag it tells me my disk is in good order and defragentation is not >>needed. >>Why the big difference in the analysis?? >> >>James

> It's not something I'd worry about. Windows Defrag when run from Start
> Menu will
> check first and then proceed if it deems defrag is needed. When OneCare
> runs
> defrag, it executes it in a mode that doesn't check, it just runs. When it
> has
> run for a long time (used to be 10 minutes, but this has been extended) it
> will
> stop and you'll get that report. It should eventually complete without the
> message if you run Tune-up fairly regularly and don't have an excessive
> number
> of large files getting fragmented on the disk.
> -steve
> --
> Stephen Boots sboots@xxxxxx
> Microsoft MVP - Windows Live
> Windows Live OneCare Forum Moderator
> http://forums.microsoft.com/windowso....aspx?siteid=2

01-12-2008

No, in other words, a design decision was made to limit the amount of time for
Defrag.
-steve
"Joe" <abc@xxxxxx> wrote:

Quote:

>In other words, it's a piece of software not well designed?
>Joe
>
>
>"StephenB" <sboots@xxxxxx> wrote in message
>news:fni8n3d7jrhdrq0b6c42v3u0f31lra6a1t@xxxxxx

Quote:

>> "JamesJ" <jjy@xxxxxx_darwin.net> wrote:
>>

	Quote:
	>>>After running Tuneup it stated that 'because of the High volume of >>>fragmentation defragmentation >>>was scheduled for a later tuneup' or something to that effect. When I run >>>an >>>analysis with Windows >>>Defrag it tells me my disk is in good order and defragentation is not >>>needed. >>>Why the big difference in the analysis?? >>> >>>James

>> It's not something I'd worry about. Windows Defrag when run from Start
>> Menu will
>> check first and then proceed if it deems defrag is needed. When OneCare
>> runs
>> defrag, it executes it in a mode that doesn't check, it just runs. When it
>> has
>> run for a long time (used to be 10 minutes, but this has been extended) it
>> will
>> stop and you'll get that report. It should eventually complete without the
>> message if you run Tune-up fairly regularly and don't have an excessive
>> number
>> of large files getting fragmented on the disk.
>> -steve
>> --
>> Stephen Boots sboots@xxxxxx
>> Microsoft MVP - Windows Live
>> Windows Live OneCare Forum Moderator
>> http://forums.microsoft.com/windowso....aspx?siteid=2

--
Stephen Boots sboots@xxxxxx
Microsoft MVP - Windows Live
Windows Live OneCare Forum Moderator
http://forums.microsoft.com/windowso....aspx?siteid=2

12-27-2007	#1 (permalink)
JamesJ Guest n/a posts	Tuneup Didn't Defrag Hard Drive After running Tuneup it stated that 'because of the High volume of fragmentation defragmentation was scheduled for a later tuneup' or something to that effect. When I run an analysis with Windows Defrag it tells me my disk is in good order and defragentation is not needed. Why the big difference in the analysis?? James
My System Specs

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Hard drive light constantly flashing ,reading hard drive during id	Sid	Vista hardware & devices	16	2 Weeks Ago 08:06 PM
Crashed hard drive...copied hard drive but can't access User area	chambersbobby	Vista General	2	04-22-2008 09:54 PM
Re: A better way to defrag your hard disk	dennis	Vista General	6	03-12-2008 06:23 PM
Re: A better way to defrag your hard disk	ray	Vista General	0	03-11-2008 12:59 PM
Transferring files from Slave XP hard drive to new Vista Hard drive - primary	Scootermc50@gmail.com	Vista installation & setup	1	05-23-2007 08:46 PM