Air versus water cooling

amplid

Vlaming
Power User
I've been wondering for some time now what the benefits and disadvantages of water cooling versus air cooling and vice versa are? The noise and dust obviously, but it those where the only ones, we'd all switch to water cooling wouldn't we? Anyone comment?

Amplid
 

My Computer

System One

  • CPU
    Intel Q9550 @ 3.2 GHz (for now)
    Motherboard
    Asus ROG Striker 2 Extreme
    Memory
    2 x 2Gb Patriot DDR3
    Graphics Card(s)
    XFX GeForce 9800 GTX+
    Sound Card
    Creative Supreme FX 2
    Monitor(s) Displays
    Neovo F417 17''
    Screen Resolution
    1280x1024
    Hard Drives
    Samsung SP2504C SATA 7200rpm
    PSU
    Pc Power & Cooling 750
    Case
    Coolermaster CM 690
    Cooling
    6 120mm's, Xigmatek HDT 1283 with crossbow backplate
    Keyboard
    Logitech G11
    Mouse
    Logitech Cordless Trackman Wheel
    Internet Speed
    ~1000 Kb/sec
Water is more cooler than air. Water is more risky than air. Water is more expensive than air. :)

Anyway, it depends if you want your temps to be very low. ;)
 

My Computer

System One

  • CPU
    Intel E8200 @ 3.4Ghz
    Motherboard
    Foxconn MARS
    Memory
    Team E-Dark 2x1G(2) 800mhz
    Graphics Card(s)
    Gainward G92 GT
    Hard Drives
    160GB
I prefer water cooling than air cooling. But there is always a danger of water leaking & watch sparks come out of my system.
 

My Computer

System One

  • CPU
    T4200 Intel
    Memory
    2 X 1GB DDR2
    Graphics Card(s)
    Intel Integrated
    Hard Drives
    1 X 250GB 7200RPM
Water cooling has never really interested me....

i can pull the same performance as any water cooled rig (with matching specs), mine just runs hotter.
you may be able to pull an extra 400-500mhz OC if your lucky
so the benefit is not high enough for me ..(performance wise)

the extra cost & risk would really only buy me ..extended component life, & in this day & age its hardly a worry.

the noise factor really don't bother me ....i only have 1x 80mm intake in the side & the HSF...but yours might be a lot louder.

if you heavily OC then it may be a useful addition.
:)
 

My Computer

System One

  • Manufacturer/Model
    ME.....
    CPU
    Q9450 @ 3.6ghz
    Motherboard
    P5K PREMIUM
    Memory
    8GB 1066mhz buffalo firestix
    Graphics Card(s)
    HD 5970
    Monitor(s) Displays
    20'' syncmaster
    Screen Resolution
    1680x1050
    Hard Drives
    160GB 7200RPM SEAGATE BARRACUDA IDE
    160GB 7200RPM SEAGATE BARRACUDA SATA 2
    PSU
    XCILIO 850w
    Case
    unknown ATX
    Cooling
    Arctic cooler pro 775
    Keyboard
    logitech EX110
    Mouse
    logitech cordless optical
    Internet Speed
    2mb
Water will let you reach those overclock speeds that Air will not let you reach, but to be honest those speeds aren't all that needed. yea games and programs do get a little better the faster your CPU goes, but it's mainly the GPU you have to worry about.

like me, I have my Q6700 from 2.67 GHz to 3.66 GHz, and I can go to 3.7 GHz but then the temps are a little higher than I'd like. I can use it, safely. but I don't wanna be near my limit all the time you know. if I wanted to go to 3.8 Ghz or higher, I'd need Water cooling. but then any game or thing I do on a quad with 3.33 GHz is basically just as good as at 3.8 GHz, except for maybe benchmarks. so in reality, it's not completely needed. but for others it may be.
 

My Computer

System One

  • CPU
    Q9650 E0 4.0 GHz @1.304v
    Motherboard
    eVGA 750i FTW
    Memory
    2x2GB Corsair Dominator PC2-8500C5D
    Graphics Card(s)
    eVGA/MSI GTX 260 SLI
    Sound Card
    X-Fi XtremeGamer
    Monitor(s) Displays
    Samsung T240 & 226BW
    Screen Resolution
    1920x1200 & 1680x1050
    Hard Drives
    Seagate Cuda 500GB 32mb Cache SATA 7200.(11) + 500GB Seagate Cuda External eSATA, USB, FW400
    PSU
    PC P&C 750w Silencer PSU
    Case
    CoolerMaster HAF 932 (Water-Cooled)
    Cooling
    Plenty of Fans, and a few 230mm Fans
    Keyboard
    Logitech G11
    Mouse
    Logitech MX-518
    Other Info
    ASUS 20x Optical, Bose Companion 3, ATH-AD500 Cans :), Patriot Xporter 16GB Flash Drive (Very Fast), & Sandisk Micro 8GB.

    Nikon D40 DSLR with 18-105mm VR & 55-200mm VR
Yeah well, not into it with this rig...:rolleyes: (boohoo!), but I'm upgrading soon (gradually, don't have much money to spend..:p). I'm interested now already, but when I tried on this one, I figured it wasn't really worth the trouble, because there'd always be my GPU bottleneck, right...

Oh well, you've convinced me: NO WATER COOLING (but you have to admit, it looks hot:D:p)

Cheers guys,

Amplid
 

My Computer

System One

  • CPU
    Intel Q9550 @ 3.2 GHz (for now)
    Motherboard
    Asus ROG Striker 2 Extreme
    Memory
    2 x 2Gb Patriot DDR3
    Graphics Card(s)
    XFX GeForce 9800 GTX+
    Sound Card
    Creative Supreme FX 2
    Monitor(s) Displays
    Neovo F417 17''
    Screen Resolution
    1280x1024
    Hard Drives
    Samsung SP2504C SATA 7200rpm
    PSU
    Pc Power & Cooling 750
    Case
    Coolermaster CM 690
    Cooling
    6 120mm's, Xigmatek HDT 1283 with crossbow backplate
    Keyboard
    Logitech G11
    Mouse
    Logitech Cordless Trackman Wheel
    Internet Speed
    ~1000 Kb/sec
Water is a more efficient conductor of heat than air, and when properly set up it therefore has the potential to move more heat out of your computer, faster. Be advised there are a bunch of cheap 'solutions' out there. And as you would expect, enthusiast advise is generally along the lines of "Go Big or Go Home", though in this case the reviews of pre-made liquid cooling products seem to back this up. I haven't seen any reviews where premade stuff beat good air cooling.

Downsides?

Expensive, more of a pain in the behind to set up, has to be maintained with regular flushes and Algicide so things don't grow in your coolant, and a failure will leak on your expensive components. Leaks are obviously very bad mojo for computer parts.

I do overclock, but don't liquid cool. If you are careful in your parts choice and diligent about maintenance, you should have no troubles. I know that I'm OK on the first part, but greatly less so on the second. And since I'm not pushing all that hard, I don't see a whole lot of point to it. Though the recent addition of a somewhat noisy 4870X2 GPU has me thinking about it again. Not really because I'm worried about temps, but rather for the potential to quiet the computer down.


My best advise is to do a LOT of research before you make the jump, if you decide to make the jump at all.


Good resources:

Danger Den <<== Seems to be the apparent leader

FrozenCPU.com | 1.877.243.8266 | World's Largest Selection of PC Modification Supplies

Quiet PC USA - Quiet Computer Hardware - Soundproofing Acoustic Material Kits
 

My Computer

System One

  • Manufacturer/Model
    Proudly Built by Me!
    CPU
    Intel Q6600
    Motherboard
    DFI UT LP P35 T2R
    Memory
    8GB OCZ Reaper DDR2 800 C44GK 4-4-4-12 2T
    Graphics Card(s)
    Sapphire Radeon 4870x2
    Sound Card
    AuzenTech Prelude 7.1
    Monitor(s) Displays
    1 Acer P243 24" and 1 Samsung T260 26" Monitor/HDTV
    Screen Resolution
    Both are running at 19x12
    Hard Drives
    Seagate 1TB 7200.11 (Vista x64)
    Seagate 500GB 7200.11 (Win 7 x64)
    PSU
    OCZ GameXtream 900w
    Other Info
    FSB at 400 (1600) Mhz, CPU Multi @ 8 for 3.2Ghz
Air coolers have just gotten so efficient these days that water cooling hardly justifies the cost. As Scotteq pointed out, unless you get a badass Danger Den setup, or something comparable, you're just wasting coin. You'll end up paying hundreds of dollars for a couple hundred MHz, over the 1GHz you can already get on air, when the reality is after that initial 1GHz, you've got more than ample cpu strengh to begin with.
 

My Computer

System One

  • Manufacturer/Model
    Fumz' Flux-Capacitor
    CPU
    E8400
    Motherboard
    DFI LP DK P35-T2RS
    Memory
    4GB G.Skill PC-1066
    Graphics Card(s)
    eVGA 8800 GTS
    Sound Card
    X-Fi XtremeGamer
    Monitor(s) Displays
    Samsung 226BW
    Screen Resolution
    1680x1050
    Hard Drives
    500GB W.D. RE2 Primary
    1TB W.D. Caviar GP WD10EACS
    PSU
    PC Power & Cooling Silencer 610
    Case
    Lian Li Lancool K62
    Cooling
    Thermalright Ultima-90/S-Flex 120mm
    Keyboard
    MS Natural Elite 4000 Ergonomic
    Mouse
    Logitech G5
    Internet Speed
    2.5MB/430
    Other Info
    D-Link DGL 4500
I prefer air aswell. Water is too risky for me and too expensive. and either way you cant get below room temperature.
 

My Computer

System One

  • Manufacturer/Model
    Wingzero
    CPU
    Intel QX 9650 OC'd to 4 GHz
    Motherboard
    EVGA 790i FTW
    Memory
    2 x 1 Gb OCZ Gold 1333 OC'd to 1600
    Graphics Card(s)
    2 EVGA 8800 GTX's OC'd
    Sound Card
    Onboard
    Monitor(s) Displays
    Samsung T240, Sharp Aquos 37 Inch
    Screen Resolution
    Too lazy to remember or look.
    Hard Drives
    200Gb Maxtor IDE
    PSU
    Corsair TX750
    Case
    NZXT Guardian
    Cooling
    Tuniq Core Contact Cooler
    Keyboard
    $15 Labtec Keyboard
    Mouse
    $10 Labtec Mouse
    Internet Speed
    Rogers Extreme
    Other Info
    3 Extra case fans with plans to add a 120mm blowhole fan soon!
A big issue that people leave out of the equation is the ambient temperature of the room the computer is sited in. That aside, with some excellent cases with large slow moving fans and a wide selection of custom CPU and GPU air cooling units, all at very reasonable prices, I feel air cooling is the way to go unless one wants to squeeze the last bit of overclock out of a CPU processor and in respect of games most games are GPU limited rather than CPU limited, so ramping up the CPU processor performance is unlikely to be much of a help in the relatively small difference between, an over-clocked processor with a custom air cooling unit and an over-clocked water cooled processor. As for looks, some of the custom CPU air-cooling units look really cool, okay not as fancy as a water-cooling set up but if they fail, you just pull out the air-cooling unit and fit another one, if a water cooling unit leaks the water can wreck anything in the computer it gets near.

http://www.techpowerup.com/reviews/Thermaltake/BigTyphoon

The above is the air-cooling unit I have fitted to my Athlon 64 4800 dualcore 939 socket, it was really easy to fit in that allthough it does require one to get at the back of the motherboard to fit it in the case of the Athlon 64 939 instilation, that was no bother to me as it was a new build instilation. I haven't got that rig over-clocked but I do appreciate it's quietness with the custom cooler on the CPU and a Gainward 7600GT GPU with passive cooling fitted in a Coolermaster Stacker case.

I really only got the Thermaltake cooler [ though it is an excellent product and I am very happy with it ] because the folks I get my kit off don't do Arctic products, but otherwise I would have gone for a cooler from Arctic

http://www.arctic-cooling.com/cpu.php


Best and Warm Regards
Adrian Wainer
 
Last edited:

My Computer

System One

  • Manufacturer/Model
    self build desktop PC
    CPU
    AMD Athlon 64 4800 dual core Toledo 2.4 gigahertz
    Motherboard
    Asus A8N-SLI Deluxe
    Memory
    4 x 1 Gigabyte sticks
    Graphics Card(s)
    Gainward 7600GT Golden Sample factory overclocked
    Sound Card
    Realtek onboard sound AC-97
    Monitor(s) Displays
    View Sonic G90B 19 inch CRT [ 17.7 visible ]
    Screen Resolution
    1600 x 900
    Hard Drives
    Hitachi HDT725032VLA36 quantity 4
    Case
    Cooler Master Stacker
    Cooling
    Thematalke Big Typhoon air cooling
    Keyboard
    Mitsumi
    Mouse
    Microsoft Intelli mouse optical tracking
    Internet Speed
    3.6 Mbps HSDPA
Get the Sunbeam core contact freezer for Intel or the thermalright ultra 120 for AMD, they are both rated #1 for those brands on frosty tech. Heres the link Top 5 Intel & AMD Heatsinks on Frostytech it's a great site.
 

My Computer

System One

  • Manufacturer/Model
    Wingzero
    CPU
    Intel QX 9650 OC'd to 4 GHz
    Motherboard
    EVGA 790i FTW
    Memory
    2 x 1 Gb OCZ Gold 1333 OC'd to 1600
    Graphics Card(s)
    2 EVGA 8800 GTX's OC'd
    Sound Card
    Onboard
    Monitor(s) Displays
    Samsung T240, Sharp Aquos 37 Inch
    Screen Resolution
    Too lazy to remember or look.
    Hard Drives
    200Gb Maxtor IDE
    PSU
    Corsair TX750
    Case
    NZXT Guardian
    Cooling
    Tuniq Core Contact Cooler
    Keyboard
    $15 Labtec Keyboard
    Mouse
    $10 Labtec Mouse
    Internet Speed
    Rogers Extreme
    Other Info
    3 Extra case fans with plans to add a 120mm blowhole fan soon!
Well I wasn't planning on switching to water at all, waay too much work..:p, just curious who'd be pro and con, and seems everybody's pro. Thanks for the threads guys;)

Cheers,

Amplid
 

My Computer

System One

  • CPU
    Intel Q9550 @ 3.2 GHz (for now)
    Motherboard
    Asus ROG Striker 2 Extreme
    Memory
    2 x 2Gb Patriot DDR3
    Graphics Card(s)
    XFX GeForce 9800 GTX+
    Sound Card
    Creative Supreme FX 2
    Monitor(s) Displays
    Neovo F417 17''
    Screen Resolution
    1280x1024
    Hard Drives
    Samsung SP2504C SATA 7200rpm
    PSU
    Pc Power & Cooling 750
    Case
    Coolermaster CM 690
    Cooling
    6 120mm's, Xigmatek HDT 1283 with crossbow backplate
    Keyboard
    Logitech G11
    Mouse
    Logitech Cordless Trackman Wheel
    Internet Speed
    ~1000 Kb/sec
New guy here and since I will be asking LOTS of Vista questions I wanted to add a slightly different perspective on this thread. I am currently building a Vista 64 machine for video editing. Even with a very fast processor, fast FSB, and a ton of RAM and disk space a single video render with modest effects and titles can last for four hours or more. During that four hours the processors are pretty much maxed, the graphics card can be working overtime, and the box is going to throw some serious heat. For these reasons I have gone initially with liquid cooled CPU and GPU cooling blocks. Later if needed I will add north & south bridge blocks and ram blocks. Yes I am paying a bit more, but considering the price of ram, motherboard, CPU, and my time it is a small investment.

I did want to address a couple of issues I saw raised.

Leaks, put things together correctly, use premium components and the system will not leak. Now a wise person will bench test the system for 24-48 hours supplying power only to the pump, but that is just SOP.

Algie, most modern coolants contain an algicide so that is not really an issue. ( you cannot just use water, that is asking for trouble )

Electrical shorts, again, most modern coolants are non-conductive and even with a leak while running will not short your system out.

Maintenance is simply changing the coolant once a year, which you should be cleaning your PC that much anyhow.

Again, it is an additional expense and I would not do it for my "home" machine, but as a needs based solution it does work nicely. ( And ya it looks pretty cool as well, lol )

Best regards,
Harry
 

My Computer

Long time reader, first time poster.

Watercooling is something I have been considering for a while now.

I'm quite experienced with air cooling..Having used several different types, modding GPU fans onto chipsets etc.....Which have all worked well I must say.

The rig I have at the moment, has a crapload of ram, an overclocked CPU, and overclocked GPU and about six fans. It goes flat out and it needs to. However the fans are just not cutting the mustard. Temps are just cranking and it makes me nervous.

When I put the pc under load, it is running absolutely flat chat load for stints of up to five or six hours....

Water cooling is becoming more appealing as each waft of hot air moves across my bench....

Summer is coming here, and I honestly think that watercooling is the way to go...

And some of the "kits" such as a couple of the Thermaltake Bigwater units ARE a somewhat cheap and reasonable place to start, whilst maintaining some quality...such as compression fittings and decent pumps/radiators.

I do see it as a massive step however.....and would be nervous as hell upgrading.
 

My Computer

System One

  • Manufacturer/Model
    My build
    CPU
    Core2Quad Q9550 yorkfield C1 3.8G
    Motherboard
    GIGABYTE GA-EP45-UD3R
    Memory
    8gig Kingston HyperX 8500 CL5
    Graphics Card(s)
    Gigabyte GTX280 1G...generally stock.
    Sound Card
    onboard
    Monitor(s) Displays
    Samsung 24" 2433bw + Benq 19" FP91G+
    Hard Drives
    2 x Samsung 500G Raid0
    1 x Samsung 1TB 32
    PSU
    Thermaltake Toughpower 850W
    Case
    Antec twelve hundred.
    Cooling
    Air...a lot of air. Thermalright 120 push/pull,8 case fans,
    Keyboard
    Logitech G15
    Mouse
    Logitech G5
    Internet Speed
    ADSL2
Back
Top