Why version with redirection output run with error?

Please, I am very confused why this script run OK:

/------------------------------------8<----------------------------------\
Start-Transcript C:\Temp\PowerShell-Transcript.log

[string[]]$ComputerNamesList = @("PC061","PC062","PC063","PC064")

for ($I=0;$I -le 4;$I++) {
$S = $ComputerNamesList[$I]
schtasks.exe /Query /FO LIST /V /S $S
}

Stop-Transcript

\------------------------------------8<----------------------------------/

but this NO:

/------------------------------------8<----------------------------------\
Start-Transcript C:\Temp\PowerShell-Transcript.log

[string[]]$ComputerNamesList = @("PC061","PC062","PC063","PC064")

for ($I=0;$I -le 4;$I++) {
$S = $ComputerNamesList[$I]
schtasks.exe /Query /FO LIST /V /S $S > Tasks.log
}

Stop-Transcript

\------------------------------------8<----------------------------------/



PS show this output:
/------------------------------------8<----------------------------------\
PS D:\W> .\Sch.ps1
Transcript started, output file is C:\Temp\PowerShell-Transcript.log
ERROR: Invalid syntax. Value expected for '/S'.
Type "SCHTASKS /QUERY /?" for usage.
Transcript stopped, output file is C:\Temp\PowerShell-Transcript.log
\------------------------------------8<----------------------------------/



In file C:\Temp\PowerShell-Transcript.log is:
/------------------------------------8<----------------------------------\
**********************
Windows PowerShell Transcript Start
Start time: 20080704174742
Username : CCV\admindavid
Machine : SRV-SIEMENS (Microsoft Windows NT 5.2.3790 Service Pack 2)
**********************
Transcript started, output file is C:\Temp\PowerShell-Transcript.log
**********************
Windows PowerShell Transcript End
End time: 20080704174745
**********************
\------------------------------------8<----------------------------------/

Hi David,

I agree with Shay. The script you have is processing 5 computer names when
you only have 4. So when the last one get's processed, $S is null and you
get an error on your call.

You don't need to use the for statement and indexing at all. You could do
this instead:

Start-Transcript C:\Temp\PowerShell-Transcript.log
[string[]]$ComputerNamesList = @("PC061","PC062","PC063","PC064")
foreach ($computer in $ComputerNamesList) {
schtasks.exe /Query /FO LIST /V /S $computer > Tasks.log
}
Stop-Transcript

That way it doesn't matter how many computers you put in your list.

--
Kirk Munro [MVP]
Poshoholic
http://poshoholic.com