![]() |
![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| Welcome to Windows Vista Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find solutions with any problems, errors or issues you are experiencing with Windows Vista. The Vista forum also covers news and updates and has an extensive Windows Vista tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks. |
| |||||||
![]() |
| |
| | #1 (permalink) |
| | Hyper-v Cluster I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in Hyper-v but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about shared iSCSI disks. I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single Hyper-V server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test things like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done in Hyper-V ? Thanks |
My System Specs![]() |
| | #2 (permalink) |
| | Re: Hyper-v Cluster Yes, but you need to use iSCSI for shared disks inside the child machines in that case (assuming you're talking Server 2k8 guests, since you're saying Exchange 2k7.) -- Charlie. http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message news:F354242C-99C8-4EF0-9429-7ECEF11D400D@newsgroup Quote: > > I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in Hyper-v > but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about shared > iSCSI disks. > > I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single Hyper-V > server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test things > like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. > > I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done in > Hyper-V ? > > Thanks > |
My System Specs![]() |
| | #3 (permalink) |
| | Re: Hyper-v Cluster Hi - thanks for the reply. Sorry - after reading my original question, I don't think I was clear what I was asking. As I said, I had found documents relating to using iSCSI for the shared storage in Hyper-V, but this was relating to failing over the hosts as well. I wanted to know if clustering could be done in one box like Virtual Server could, with no extra external storage. I want to familiarise myself with clustering in W2008 and Exch2007 but don't have the hardware to set up extra storage. Thanks "Charlie Russel - MVP" wrote: Quote: > Yes, but you need to use iSCSI for shared disks inside the child machines in > that case (assuming you're talking Server 2k8 guests, since you're saying > Exchange 2k7.) > > -- > Charlie. > http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 > http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel > > > "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message > news:F354242C-99C8-4EF0-9429-7ECEF11D400D@newsgroup Quote: > > > > I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in Hyper-v > > but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about shared > > iSCSI disks. > > > > I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single Hyper-V > > server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test things > > like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. > > > > I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done in > > Hyper-V ? > > > > Thanks > > > |
My System Specs![]() |
| | #4 (permalink) |
| | Re: Hyper-v Cluster No, it can't. BUT if you get yourself an iSCSI software package, you can do it by creating an iSCSI server out of a basic Windows Server. Server 2k8 doesn't do clustering the same way as Server 2k3, and you can't use the hyper-v SCSI disk (VHD) type for clustering. It's a change in the clustering requirements for Server 2k8. -- Charlie. http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message news:F3194852-292C-4B41-B851-765BBA9E76AA@newsgroup Quote: > Hi - thanks for the reply. > > Sorry - after reading my original question, I don't think I was clear what > I > was asking. > > As I said, I had found documents relating to using iSCSI for the shared > storage in Hyper-V, but this was relating to failing over the hosts as > well. > > I wanted to know if clustering could be done in one box like Virtual > Server > could, with no extra external storage. I want to familiarise myself with > clustering in W2008 and Exch2007 but don't have the hardware to set up > extra > storage. > > Thanks > > > "Charlie Russel - MVP" wrote: > Quote: >> Yes, but you need to use iSCSI for shared disks inside the child machines >> in >> that case (assuming you're talking Server 2k8 guests, since you're saying >> Exchange 2k7.) >> >> -- >> Charlie. >> http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 >> http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel >> >> >> "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message >> news:F354242C-99C8-4EF0-9429-7ECEF11D400D@newsgroup Quote: >> > >> > I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in >> > Hyper-v >> > but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about >> > shared >> > iSCSI disks. >> > >> > I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single >> > Hyper-V >> > server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test >> > things >> > like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. >> > >> > I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done in >> > Hyper-V ? >> > >> > Thanks >> > >> |
My System Specs![]() |
| | #5 (permalink) |
| | Re: Hyper-v Cluster I was more than a little disappointed myself when I set up a SCSI disk and was unable to select it as clustered storage. I find this odd as an SCSI device *should* be capable of multiple mounting at hardware level (by definition it's part of the SCSI language set.) It's hardly an SCSI device if it doesn't support this...we must be missing something. "Charlie Russel - MVP" <charlie@newsgroup> wrote in message news:uvJ4wUJDKHA.4376@newsgroup Quote: > No, it can't. BUT if you get yourself an iSCSI software package, you can > do it by creating an iSCSI server out of a basic Windows Server. Server > 2k8 doesn't do clustering the same way as Server 2k3, and you can't use > the hyper-v SCSI disk (VHD) type for clustering. It's a change in the > clustering requirements for Server 2k8. > > -- > Charlie. > http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 > http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel > > > "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message > news:F3194852-292C-4B41-B851-765BBA9E76AA@newsgroup Quote: >> Hi - thanks for the reply. >> >> Sorry - after reading my original question, I don't think I was clear >> what I >> was asking. >> >> As I said, I had found documents relating to using iSCSI for the shared >> storage in Hyper-V, but this was relating to failing over the hosts as >> well. >> >> I wanted to know if clustering could be done in one box like Virtual >> Server >> could, with no extra external storage. I want to familiarise myself with >> clustering in W2008 and Exch2007 but don't have the hardware to set up >> extra >> storage. >> >> Thanks >> >> >> "Charlie Russel - MVP" wrote: >> Quote: >>> Yes, but you need to use iSCSI for shared disks inside the child >>> machines in >>> that case (assuming you're talking Server 2k8 guests, since you're >>> saying >>> Exchange 2k7.) >>> >>> -- >>> Charlie. >>> http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 >>> http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel >>> >>> >>> "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message >>> news:F354242C-99C8-4EF0-9429-7ECEF11D400D@newsgroup >>> > >>> > I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in >>> > Hyper-v >>> > but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about >>> > shared >>> > iSCSI disks. >>> > >>> > I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single >>> > Hyper-V >>> > server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test >>> > things >>> > like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. >>> > >>> > I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done >>> > in >>> > Hyper-V ? >>> > >>> > Thanks >>> > >>> >>> |
My System Specs![]() |
| | #6 (permalink) |
| | Re: Hyper-v Cluster Yeah, I was annoyed at the time, but it's been nearly 3 years now and I'm over it. There are perfectly adequate iSCSI solutions out there. Use oneof them. -- Charlie. http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel "Steve Buckley" <mrnecros(remove-this)@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:emAiU6TDKHA.1488@newsgroup Quote: >I was more than a little disappointed myself when I set up a SCSI disk and >was unable to select it as clustered storage. > I find this odd as an SCSI device *should* be capable of multiple mounting > at hardware level (by definition it's part of the SCSI language set.) > It's hardly an SCSI device if it doesn't support this...we must be missing > something. > > "Charlie Russel - MVP" <charlie@newsgroup> wrote in message > news:uvJ4wUJDKHA.4376@newsgroup Quote: >> No, it can't. BUT if you get yourself an iSCSI software package, you can >> do it by creating an iSCSI server out of a basic Windows Server. Server >> 2k8 doesn't do clustering the same way as Server 2k3, and you can't use >> the hyper-v SCSI disk (VHD) type for clustering. It's a change in the >> clustering requirements for Server 2k8. >> >> -- >> Charlie. >> http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 >> http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel >> >> >> "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message >> news:F3194852-292C-4B41-B851-765BBA9E76AA@newsgroup Quote: >>> Hi - thanks for the reply. >>> >>> Sorry - after reading my original question, I don't think I was clear >>> what I >>> was asking. >>> >>> As I said, I had found documents relating to using iSCSI for the shared >>> storage in Hyper-V, but this was relating to failing over the hosts as >>> well. >>> >>> I wanted to know if clustering could be done in one box like Virtual >>> Server >>> could, with no extra external storage. I want to familiarise myself with >>> clustering in W2008 and Exch2007 but don't have the hardware to set up >>> extra >>> storage. >>> >>> Thanks >>> >>> >>> "Charlie Russel - MVP" wrote: >>> >>>> Yes, but you need to use iSCSI for shared disks inside the child >>>> machines in >>>> that case (assuming you're talking Server 2k8 guests, since you're >>>> saying >>>> Exchange 2k7.) >>>> >>>> -- >>>> Charlie. >>>> http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 >>>> http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel >>>> >>>> >>>> "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message >>>> news:F354242C-99C8-4EF0-9429-7ECEF11D400D@newsgroup >>>> > >>>> > I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in >>>> > Hyper-v >>>> > but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about >>>> > shared >>>> > iSCSI disks. >>>> > >>>> > I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single >>>> > Hyper-V >>>> > server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test >>>> > things >>>> > like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. >>>> > >>>> > I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done >>>> > in >>>> > Hyper-V ? >>>> > >>>> > Thanks >>>> > >>>> >>>> |
My System Specs![]() |
| | #7 (permalink) |
| | Re: Hyper-v Cluster Step-by-step guide to creating an iSCSI target machine in Hyper-V using Openfiler (Opensource Freeware) http://searchstorage.techtarget.com....rosoft-Hyper-V The most recent version of Openfiler has had some layout changes to the web interface used in the walk-through but it's more or less the same process. Be sure to scroll to the bottom of web-pages as some vital features (like "create partition") lurk there. "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message news:F354242C-99C8-4EF0-9429-7ECEF11D400D@newsgroup Quote: > > I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in Hyper-v > but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about shared > iSCSI disks. > > I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single Hyper-V > server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test things > like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. > > I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done in > Hyper-V ? > > Thanks > |
My System Specs![]() |
| | #8 (permalink) |
| | Ooops, OpenFiler is a dud. Although 2008 can mount an OpenFiler volume it does not support SCSI-3 Persistant Reservations so it can't be managed by the Failover Clustering service. The freeware version of StarWind supports 2 nodes for cluster testing which is OK for basic qarum based clustering. Still need to find something suitable for Majority Node Set clusters (need a minumum of 3 nodes for that.) "Steve Buckley" <mrnecros(remove-this)@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:%23yIoYblDKHA.1340@newsgroup Quote: > Step-by-step guide to creating an iSCSI target machine in Hyper-V using > Openfiler (Opensource Freeware) > http://searchstorage.techtarget.com....rosoft-Hyper-V > > The most recent version of Openfiler has had some layout changes to the > web interface used in the walk-through but it's more or less the same > process. > Be sure to scroll to the bottom of web-pages as some vital features (like > "create partition") lurk there. > > "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message > news:F354242C-99C8-4EF0-9429-7ECEF11D400D@newsgroup Quote: >> >> I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in >> Hyper-v >> but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about shared >> iSCSI disks. >> >> I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single Hyper-V >> server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test things >> like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. >> >> I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done in >> Hyper-V ? >> >> Thanks >> |
My System Specs![]() |
| | #9 (permalink) |
| | Re: Hyper-v Cluster This is due to the change in clustering for Windows 2008 and above that requires SCSI-3 Persistent Reservation support. Parallel SCSI does not support this feature and that is what the SCSI emulator emulates. As has been noted earlier, iSCSI is the preferred solution for guest clustering. -- Geoff N. Hiten Principal SQL Infrastructure Consultant Microsoft SQL Server MVP "Steve Buckley" <mrnecros(remove-this)@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:emAiU6TDKHA.1488@newsgroup Quote: >I was more than a little disappointed myself when I set up a SCSI disk and >was unable to select it as clustered storage. > I find this odd as an SCSI device *should* be capable of multiple mounting > at hardware level (by definition it's part of the SCSI language set.) > It's hardly an SCSI device if it doesn't support this...we must be missing > something. > > "Charlie Russel - MVP" <charlie@newsgroup> wrote in message > news:uvJ4wUJDKHA.4376@newsgroup Quote: >> No, it can't. BUT if you get yourself an iSCSI software package, you can >> do it by creating an iSCSI server out of a basic Windows Server. Server >> 2k8 doesn't do clustering the same way as Server 2k3, and you can't use >> the hyper-v SCSI disk (VHD) type for clustering. It's a change in the >> clustering requirements for Server 2k8. >> >> -- >> Charlie. >> http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 >> http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel >> >> >> "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message >> news:F3194852-292C-4B41-B851-765BBA9E76AA@newsgroup Quote: >>> Hi - thanks for the reply. >>> >>> Sorry - after reading my original question, I don't think I was clear >>> what I >>> was asking. >>> >>> As I said, I had found documents relating to using iSCSI for the shared >>> storage in Hyper-V, but this was relating to failing over the hosts as >>> well. >>> >>> I wanted to know if clustering could be done in one box like Virtual >>> Server >>> could, with no extra external storage. I want to familiarise myself with >>> clustering in W2008 and Exch2007 but don't have the hardware to set up >>> extra >>> storage. >>> >>> Thanks >>> >>> >>> "Charlie Russel - MVP" wrote: >>> >>>> Yes, but you need to use iSCSI for shared disks inside the child >>>> machines in >>>> that case (assuming you're talking Server 2k8 guests, since you're >>>> saying >>>> Exchange 2k7.) >>>> >>>> -- >>>> Charlie. >>>> http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 >>>> http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel >>>> >>>> >>>> "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message >>>> news:F354242C-99C8-4EF0-9429-7ECEF11D400D@newsgroup >>>> > >>>> > I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in >>>> > Hyper-v >>>> > but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about >>>> > shared >>>> > iSCSI disks. >>>> > >>>> > I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single >>>> > Hyper-V >>>> > server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test >>>> > things >>>> > like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. >>>> > >>>> > I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done >>>> > in >>>> > Hyper-V ? >>>> > >>>> > Thanks >>>> > >>>> >>>> |
My System Specs![]() |
| | #10 (permalink) |
| | Re: Hyper-v Cluster You must admit though, it makes the virtual SCSI device type quite useless though, may as well just offer virtual IDE type devices. Maybe they will fix it later but for now it's a white elephant. StarWind iSCSI seems to work fine though if you load it on the Hyper-V host server using an image file device so at least it's not a complete dead end. "Geoff N. Hiten" <SQLCraftsman@newsgroup> wrote in message news:uVQQOnxDKHA.3708@newsgroup Quote: > This is due to the change in clustering for Windows 2008 and above that > requires SCSI-3 Persistent Reservation support. Parallel SCSI does not > support this feature and that is what the SCSI emulator emulates. > As has been noted earlier, iSCSI is the preferred solution for guest > clustering. > > -- > Geoff N. Hiten > Principal SQL Infrastructure Consultant > Microsoft SQL Server MVP > > > > "Steve Buckley" <mrnecros(remove-this)@hotmail.com> wrote in message > news:emAiU6TDKHA.1488@newsgroup Quote: >>I was more than a little disappointed myself when I set up a SCSI disk and >>was unable to select it as clustered storage. >> I find this odd as an SCSI device *should* be capable of multiple >> mounting at hardware level (by definition it's part of the SCSI language >> set.) >> It's hardly an SCSI device if it doesn't support this...we must be >> missing something. >> >> "Charlie Russel - MVP" <charlie@newsgroup> wrote in message >> news:uvJ4wUJDKHA.4376@newsgroup Quote: >>> No, it can't. BUT if you get yourself an iSCSI software package, you can >>> do it by creating an iSCSI server out of a basic Windows Server. Server >>> 2k8 doesn't do clustering the same way as Server 2k3, and you can't use >>> the hyper-v SCSI disk (VHD) type for clustering. It's a change in the >>> clustering requirements for Server 2k8. >>> >>> -- >>> Charlie. >>> http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 >>> http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel >>> >>> >>> "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message >>> news:F3194852-292C-4B41-B851-765BBA9E76AA@newsgroup >>>> Hi - thanks for the reply. >>>> >>>> Sorry - after reading my original question, I don't think I was clear >>>> what I >>>> was asking. >>>> >>>> As I said, I had found documents relating to using iSCSI for the shared >>>> storage in Hyper-V, but this was relating to failing over the hosts as >>>> well. >>>> >>>> I wanted to know if clustering could be done in one box like Virtual >>>> Server >>>> could, with no extra external storage. I want to familiarise myself >>>> with >>>> clustering in W2008 and Exch2007 but don't have the hardware to set up >>>> extra >>>> storage. >>>> >>>> Thanks >>>> >>>> >>>> "Charlie Russel - MVP" wrote: >>>> >>>>> Yes, but you need to use iSCSI for shared disks inside the child >>>>> machines in >>>>> that case (assuming you're talking Server 2k8 guests, since you're >>>>> saying >>>>> Exchange 2k7.) >>>>> >>>>> -- >>>>> Charlie. >>>>> http://msmvps.com/blogs/xperts64 >>>>> http://mvp.support.microsoft.com/profile/charlie.russel >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> "jar" <jar@newsgroup> wrote in message >>>>> news:F354242C-99C8-4EF0-9429-7ECEF11D400D@newsgroup >>>>> > >>>>> > I have found some documents explaining how to set up clustering in >>>>> > Hyper-v >>>>> > but this is for clustering the host servers. These docs talk about >>>>> > shared >>>>> > iSCSI disks. >>>>> > >>>>> > I would like to set up clustering, for test purposes, in a single >>>>> > Hyper-V >>>>> > server - so would like to cluster the guest machines so I can test >>>>> > things >>>>> > like failover clustering and Exchange 2007 clustering. >>>>> > >>>>> > I know this could be done in Virtual Server but can it still be done >>>>> > in >>>>> > Hyper-V ? >>>>> > >>>>> > Thanks >>>>> > >>>>> >>>>> >>> |
My System Specs![]() |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Forum | |||
| Backing up Hyper-V cluster with Data Protection Manager 2007 | Virtual Server | |||
| Hyper-V Cluster Problems/Bug Reporting | Virtual Server | |||
| Removing Hyper-V VMs From a Cluster | Virtual Server | |||
| Cannot manage an Hyper-V on Core from a full installed W2K8 with Hyper-V... | Virtual Server | |||
| Built a Windows 2008 Fail over Cluster running Hyper-V: articlesavailable if you are interested | Virtual Server | |||