Windows Vista Forums
Vista Forums Home Join Vista Forums Windows 7 Forum Vista Tutorials Tags
Welcome to Windows Vista Forums. Our forum is dedicated to helping you find solutions with any problems, errors or issues you are experiencing with Windows Vista. The Vista forum also covers news and updates and has an extensive Windows Vista tutorial section that covers a wide range of tips and tricks.

Go Back   Vista Forums > Vista Newsgroups > Vista General

Vista - Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

Reply
 
Old 02-01-2007   #1 (permalink)
Colin Barnhorst


 
 

Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It
turns out that an upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting up
dual boot systems. I must admitted I am surprised that an installation
using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume other than the OS
being upgraded is tolerated.

The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the
upgrade matrix) so far are:

Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1
empty. 768MB ram.

Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k desktop.
Disk Options are not available, therefore modifications to the disks are not
possible from Setup (no ability to format the target from within Setup).
Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to running Vista Setup.
Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of disk 0 or disk
1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista to drive E: and a
dual boot options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as expected.

Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1 is
empty. 512MB of ram.

Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP desktop.
As expected, disk options are not available, yada yada yada. Again the
custom option permits a choice of target volume and selection of drive 1
results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista fully functional.

This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of the
legacy system, but it is not blocked.

I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to check
if there is any difference. I am also going to spend some time on the x64
scenarios to see what additional tools are available and to investigate the
very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk with XP Pro x64 and Vista
x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual machines because of the
licensing issue so this all takes some time.



My System SpecsSystem Spec
Old 02-01-2007   #2 (permalink)
MICHAEL


 
 

Re: Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

Great information, Colin.

I have been wondering where you had been all day...
you've been busy.

Please, help clear up some the confusion.

-Michael

"Colin Barnhorst" <colinbarharst@msn.com> wrote in message
news:774FA305-7DE2-45A1-96F0-F6B6E7F2B45F@microsoft.com...
>I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It turns out that an
>upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting up dual boot systems. I must admitted I
>am surprised that an installation using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume
>other than the OS being upgraded is tolerated.
>
> The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the upgrade matrix) so far
> are:
>
> Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1 empty. 768MB ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k desktop. Disk Options are
> not available, therefore modifications to the disks are not possible from Setup (no ability
> to format the target from within Setup). Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to
> running Vista Setup. Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of disk 0 or
> disk 1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista to drive E: and a dual boot
> options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as expected.
>
> Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1 is empty. 512MB of
> ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP desktop. As expected, disk
> options are not available, yada yada yada. Again the custom option permits a choice of
> target volume and selection of drive 1 results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista
> fully functional.
>
> This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of the legacy system, but
> it is not blocked.
>
> I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to check if there is any
> difference. I am also going to spend some time on the x64 scenarios to see what additional
> tools are available and to investigate the very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk
> with XP Pro x64 and Vista x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual machines because
> of the licensing issue so this all takes some time.
>
>


My System SpecsSystem Spec
Old 02-01-2007   #3 (permalink)
Rock


 
 

Re: Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

"Colin Barnhorst" wrote

>I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It
>turns out that an upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting up
>dual boot systems. I must admitted I am surprised that an installation
>using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume other than the OS
>being upgraded is tolerated.
>
> The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the
> upgrade matrix) so far are:
>
> Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1
> empty. 768MB ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k
> desktop. Disk Options are not available, therefore modifications to the
> disks are not possible from Setup (no ability to format the target from
> within Setup). Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to running
> Vista Setup. Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of
> disk 0 or disk 1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista to
> drive E: and a dual boot options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as expected.
>
> Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1 is
> empty. 512MB of ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP
> desktop. As expected, disk options are not available, yada yada yada.
> Again the custom option permits a choice of target volume and selection of
> drive 1 results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista fully
> functional.
>
> This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of the
> legacy system, but it is not blocked.
>
> I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to
> check if there is any difference. I am also going to spend some time on
> the x64 scenarios to see what additional tools are available and to
> investigate the very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk with XP
> Pro x64 and Vista x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual
> machines because of the licensing issue so this all takes some time.


Thanks Colin. Yes, it's surprising the dual boot is not blocked. Are you
going to do the double install method for installing with an upgrade pk
without the qualifying OS to see what happens?

--
Rock [MVP - User/Shell]

My System SpecsSystem Spec
Old 02-01-2007   #4 (permalink)
Colin Barnhorst


 
 

Re: Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

No. I bought VHP upgrade edition off of Amazon so I could run these tests.
I plan to give it to my grandson when I am done. I am being careful not to
activate on any of the tests and that scenario should include activation to
see if it really works. What I am actually doing is installing from an MSDN
dvd using just the pk from the purchased box. I want to keep my gift fresh
so anything requiring activation is out. Naturally I uncheck the "activate
when I get online" box each run.

Anyway, that scenario may be outside of the scope of the license and I am
being very very wary about advising users to use it. My advice is don't
unless you have checked with a Microsoft local office for an official
opinion. I don't use upgrade edititions so I don't really care.

"Rock" <rock@nospam.net> wrote in message
news:uPPZDSoRHHA.1600@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
> "Colin Barnhorst" wrote
>
>>I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It
>>turns out that an upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting up
>>dual boot systems. I must admitted I am surprised that an installation
>>using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume other than the OS
>>being upgraded is tolerated.
>>
>> The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the
>> upgrade matrix) so far are:
>>
>> Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1
>> empty. 768MB ram.
>>
>> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k
>> desktop. Disk Options are not available, therefore modifications to the
>> disks are not possible from Setup (no ability to format the target from
>> within Setup). Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to running
>> Vista Setup. Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of
>> disk 0 or disk 1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista
>> to drive E: and a dual boot options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as
>> expected.
>>
>> Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1 is
>> empty. 512MB of ram.
>>
>> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP
>> desktop. As expected, disk options are not available, yada yada yada.
>> Again the custom option permits a choice of target volume and selection
>> of drive 1 results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista fully
>> functional.
>>
>> This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of
>> the legacy system, but it is not blocked.
>>
>> I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to
>> check if there is any difference. I am also going to spend some time on
>> the x64 scenarios to see what additional tools are available and to
>> investigate the very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk with XP
>> Pro x64 and Vista x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual
>> machines because of the licensing issue so this all takes some time.

>
> Thanks Colin. Yes, it's surprising the dual boot is not blocked. Are you
> going to do the double install method for installing with an upgrade pk
> without the qualifying OS to see what happens?
>
> --
> Rock [MVP - User/Shell]


My System SpecsSystem Spec
Old 02-02-2007   #5 (permalink)
Dennis Pack


 
 

Re: Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

Colin:
Great work. I looks like the information that we've been given is
how the system should work on paper, but how it works in reality is another
story. Have a great day.

--
Dennis Pack
XP x64, Vista Enterprise x64
Office2007
"Colin Barnhorst" <colinbarharst@msn.com> wrote in message
news:774FA305-7DE2-45A1-96F0-F6B6E7F2B45F@microsoft.com...
>I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It
>turns out that an upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting up
>dual boot systems. I must admitted I am surprised that an installation
>using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume other than the OS
>being upgraded is tolerated.
>
> The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the
> upgrade matrix) so far are:
>
> Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1
> empty. 768MB ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k
> desktop. Disk Options are not available, therefore modifications to the
> disks are not possible from Setup (no ability to format the target from
> within Setup). Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to running
> Vista Setup. Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of
> disk 0 or disk 1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista to
> drive E: and a dual boot options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as expected.
>
> Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1 is
> empty. 512MB of ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP
> desktop. As expected, disk options are not available, yada yada yada.
> Again the custom option permits a choice of target volume and selection of
> drive 1 results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista fully
> functional.
>
> This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of the
> legacy system, but it is not blocked.
>
> I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to
> check if there is any difference. I am also going to spend some time on
> the x64 scenarios to see what additional tools are available and to
> investigate the very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk with XP
> Pro x64 and Vista x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual
> machines because of the licensing issue so this all takes some time.
>
>


My System SpecsSystem Spec
Old 02-02-2007   #6 (permalink)
Chad Harris


 
 

Re: Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

Good work and good information.

I've been wondering what the purpose of the choice of editions when you
install is, since the code is the code and what is going to set up is
determined by the code on the DVD. If you don't have the code for MCE or bit
locker, on Vista Business, it's not going to show up because you check
"Ultimate."

I wonder if it only shows up when you bypass putting in a product key. I
setup Vista today and it completed expanding files>rebooted>asked me to put
in the PK again in setup. It wouldn't take the PK the second time, so I
bypassed it, then decided to abort it and went back to an XP boot and when I
realized that there was a normal sized Vista on the drive through
Diskmangement, I restarted and selected Vista and it booted up to complete
the setup. So I can't remember if the the pull down for editions will
occur if you put the product key in but I'm pretty sure it doesn't.

CH


"Colin Barnhorst" <colinbarharst@msn.com> wrote in message
news:774FA305-7DE2-45A1-96F0-F6B6E7F2B45F@microsoft.com...
>I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It
>turns out that an upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting up
>dual boot systems. I must admitted I am surprised that an installation
>using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume other than the OS
>being upgraded is tolerated.
>
> The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the
> upgrade matrix) so far are:
>
> Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1
> empty. 768MB ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k
> desktop. Disk Options are not available, therefore modifications to the
> disks are not possible from Setup (no ability to format the target from
> within Setup). Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to running
> Vista Setup. Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of
> disk 0 or disk 1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista to
> drive E: and a dual boot options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as expected.
>
> Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1 is
> empty. 512MB of ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP
> desktop. As expected, disk options are not available, yada yada yada.
> Again the custom option permits a choice of target volume and selection of
> drive 1 results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista fully
> functional.
>
> This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of the
> legacy system, but it is not blocked.
>
> I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to
> check if there is any difference. I am also going to spend some time on
> the x64 scenarios to see what additional tools are available and to
> investigate the very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk with XP
> Pro x64 and Vista x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual
> machines because of the licensing issue so this all takes some time.
>
>


My System SpecsSystem Spec
Old 02-02-2007   #7 (permalink)
Colin Barnhorst


 
 

Re: Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

I forgot to mention that the time to do a custom install is affected
adversely by ram below 768MB. At 512MB the "expanding files" stage takes
much longer than at 768MB. Other stages are about the same at 512MB as
768MB. Ram above 768MB does not have much effect on the time for expanding
files. 768MB seems to be about the sweet spot for quick custom
installations.

"Colin Barnhorst" <colinbarharst@msn.com> wrote in message
news:774FA305-7DE2-45A1-96F0-F6B6E7F2B45F@microsoft.com...
>I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It
>turns out that an upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting up
>dual boot systems. I must admitted I am surprised that an installation
>using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume other than the OS
>being upgraded is tolerated.
>
> The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the
> upgrade matrix) so far are:
>
> Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1
> empty. 768MB ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k
> desktop. Disk Options are not available, therefore modifications to the
> disks are not possible from Setup (no ability to format the target from
> within Setup). Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to running
> Vista Setup. Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of
> disk 0 or disk 1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista to
> drive E: and a dual boot options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as expected.
>
> Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1 is
> empty. 512MB of ram.
>
> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP
> desktop. As expected, disk options are not available, yada yada yada.
> Again the custom option permits a choice of target volume and selection of
> drive 1 results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista fully
> functional.
>
> This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of the
> legacy system, but it is not blocked.
>
> I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to
> check if there is any difference. I am also going to spend some time on
> the x64 scenarios to see what additional tools are available and to
> investigate the very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk with XP
> Pro x64 and Vista x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual
> machines because of the licensing issue so this all takes some time.
>
>


My System SpecsSystem Spec
Old 02-02-2007   #8 (permalink)
Colin Barnhorst


 
 

Re: Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

The choice of editions is when you bypass entering the pk. It knows what
edition you want when you put in the pk so it doesn't need to ask.

The dvd contains manifests for each edition. I don't think that there are
different manifests for upgrade or full. However, the pk tells Setup
whether you are licensing as a full or upgrade edition and so changes the
behavior of Setup, but not the content of the edition you are installing.
That is determined by the manifest. A pk for Ultimate will get you the same
Ultimate regardless of whether the pk is upgrade or full.

The Windows image file contains all possible files for all editions of
Vista. No file appears twice (single-instancing) even if the manifest calls
for multiple installations of the same file during an installation. The
manifest for each edition tells Setup what to use from the Wim file to
install the edition. This is how they got all the editions on one dvd.

"Chad Harris" <vistaneedsmuchowork.net> wrote in message
news:ObmuFroRHHA.4844@TK2MSFTNGP03.phx.gbl...
> Good work and good information.
>
> I've been wondering what the purpose of the choice of editions when you
> install is, since the code is the code and what is going to set up is
> determined by the code on the DVD. If you don't have the code for MCE or
> bit locker, on Vista Business, it's not going to show up because you
> check "Ultimate."
>
> I wonder if it only shows up when you bypass putting in a product key. I
> setup Vista today and it completed expanding files>rebooted>asked me to
> put in the PK again in setup. It wouldn't take the PK the second time, so
> I bypassed it, then decided to abort it and went back to an XP boot and
> when I realized that there was a normal sized Vista on the drive through
> Diskmangement, I restarted and selected Vista and it booted up to complete
> the setup. So I can't remember if the the pull down for editions will
> occur if you put the product key in but I'm pretty sure it doesn't.
>
> CH
>
>
> "Colin Barnhorst" <colinbarharst@msn.com> wrote in message
> news:774FA305-7DE2-45A1-96F0-F6B6E7F2B45F@microsoft.com...
>>I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It
>>turns out that an upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting up
>>dual boot systems. I must admitted I am surprised that an installation
>>using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume other than the OS
>>being upgraded is tolerated.
>>
>> The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the
>> upgrade matrix) so far are:
>>
>> Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1
>> empty. 768MB ram.
>>
>> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k
>> desktop. Disk Options are not available, therefore modifications to the
>> disks are not possible from Setup (no ability to format the target from
>> within Setup). Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to running
>> Vista Setup. Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of
>> disk 0 or disk 1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista
>> to drive E: and a dual boot options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as
>> expected.
>>
>> Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1 is
>> empty. 512MB of ram.
>>
>> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP
>> desktop. As expected, disk options are not available, yada yada yada.
>> Again the custom option permits a choice of target volume and selection
>> of drive 1 results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista fully
>> functional.
>>
>> This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of
>> the legacy system, but it is not blocked.
>>
>> I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to
>> check if there is any difference. I am also going to spend some time on
>> the x64 scenarios to see what additional tools are available and to
>> investigate the very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk with XP
>> Pro x64 and Vista x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual
>> machines because of the licensing issue so this all takes some time.
>>
>>

>


My System SpecsSystem Spec
Old 02-02-2007   #9 (permalink)
Rock


 
 

Re: Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

Lol, I didn't think you would.

"Colin Barnhorst" <colinbarharst@msn.com> wrote in message
news:uJVQKaoRHHA.4076@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
> No. I bought VHP upgrade edition off of Amazon so I could run these
> tests. I plan to give it to my grandson when I am done. I am being
> careful not to activate on any of the tests and that scenario should
> include activation to see if it really works. What I am actually doing is
> installing from an MSDN dvd using just the pk from the purchased box. I
> want to keep my gift fresh so anything requiring activation is out.
> Naturally I uncheck the "activate when I get online" box each run.
>
> Anyway, that scenario may be outside of the scope of the license and I am
> being very very wary about advising users to use it. My advice is don't
> unless you have checked with a Microsoft local office for an official
> opinion. I don't use upgrade edititions so I don't really care.
>
> "Rock" <rock@nospam.net> wrote in message
> news:uPPZDSoRHHA.1600@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
>> "Colin Barnhorst" wrote
>>
>>>I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It
>>>turns out that an upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting
>>>up dual boot systems. I must admitted I am surprised that an
>>>installation using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume
>>>other than the OS being upgraded is tolerated.
>>>
>>> The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the
>>> upgrade matrix) so far are:
>>>
>>> Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1
>>> empty. 768MB ram.
>>>
>>> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k
>>> desktop. Disk Options are not available, therefore modifications to the
>>> disks are not possible from Setup (no ability to format the target from
>>> within Setup). Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to running
>>> Vista Setup. Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of
>>> disk 0 or disk 1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista
>>> to drive E: and a dual boot options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as
>>> expected.
>>>
>>> Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1
>>> is empty. 512MB of ram.
>>>
>>> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP
>>> desktop. As expected, disk options are not available, yada yada yada.
>>> Again the custom option permits a choice of target volume and selection
>>> of drive 1 results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista fully
>>> functional.
>>>
>>> This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of
>>> the legacy system, but it is not blocked.
>>>
>>> I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to
>>> check if there is any difference. I am also going to spend some time on
>>> the x64 scenarios to see what additional tools are available and to
>>> investigate the very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk with
>>> XP Pro x64 and Vista x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual
>>> machines because of the licensing issue so this all takes some time.

>>
>> Thanks Colin. Yes, it's surprising the dual boot is not blocked. Are
>> you going to do the double install method for installing with an upgrade
>> pk without the qualifying OS to see what happens?


--
Rock [MVP - User/Shell]

My System SpecsSystem Spec
Old 02-02-2007   #10 (permalink)
Bill Condie


 
 

Re: Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (yellow dot scenarios)

Could someone explain these Yellow dots and Green dots?

"MICHAEL" <u158627_emr@dslr.net> wrote in message
news:%23%23AaTCoRHHA.3812@TK2MSFTNGP06.phx.gbl...
> Great information, Colin.
>
> I have been wondering where you had been all day...
> you've been busy.
>
> Please, help clear up some the confusion.
>
> -Michael
>
> "Colin Barnhorst" <colinbarharst@msn.com> wrote in message
> news:774FA305-7DE2-45A1-96F0-F6B6E7F2B45F@microsoft.com...
>>I have been running tests today with an upgrade edition product key. It
>>turns out that an upgrade edition product key is sufficient for setting up
>>dual boot systems. I must admitted I am surprised that an installation
>>using an upgrade edition product key to a target volume other than the OS
>>being upgraded is tolerated.
>>
>> The results of x86 scenarios with upgrade disabled (yellow dots in the
>> upgrade matrix) so far are:
>>
>> Dual drive system with Windows 2000 Professional SP4 on drive 0, drive 1
>> empty. 768MB ram.
>>
>> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the W2k
>> desktop. Disk Options are not available, therefore modifications to the
>> disks are not possible from Setup (no ability to format the target from
>> within Setup). Any modifications need to be made in W2k prior to running
>> Vista Setup. Upgrade option disabled. Custom option permits a choice of
>> disk 0 or disk 1. Selection of disk 1 results in installation of Vista
>> to drive E: and a dual boot options menu. Both W2k and VHP boot as
>> expected.
>>
>> Dual drive system with Windows XP Professional SP2 on drive 0, drive 1 is
>> empty. 512MB of ram.
>>
>> Ran Vista x86 Setup with an upgrade edition pk for VHP from the XP
>> desktop. As expected, disk options are not available, yada yada yada.
>> Again the custom option permits a choice of target volume and selection
>> of drive 1 results in a dual boot system with both XP and Vista fully
>> functional.
>>
>> This appears to violate the EULA since it permits the continued use of
>> the legacy system, but it is not blocked.
>>
>> I am about to switch to the upgrade-enabled scenarios (green dots) to
>> check if there is any difference. I am also going to spend some time on
>> the x64 scenarios to see what additional tools are available and to
>> investigate the very discouraging results using an x86 upgrade pk with XP
>> Pro x64 and Vista x64 as the legacy systems. I am not using virtual
>> machines because of the licensing issue so this all takes some time.
>>
>>

>



My System SpecsSystem Spec
Reply

Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Forum
Dual Booting XP & Vista Vista installation & setup
Windows Vista Editions upgrade eligibility (FPP) Vista General
Dual Booting and can't Upgrade Vista General
Vista upgrade dual-booting with original XP Vista installation & setup
Dual booting with Vista upgrade editions (green dot scenarios) Vista General


Vista Forums is an independent web site and has not been authorized,
sponsored, or otherwise approved by Microsoft Corporation.
"Windows Vista", the Start Orb, and related materials are trademarks of Microsoft Corp.
© Designer Media Ltd

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46