Thanks skirwin.
1. I note your observation regarding Microsoft's implementation of
sleep/hibernate on Vista which is well-supported by the number of KB articles
on such topics on their support website. BUT, - don't hold your breath about
all of these problems being fixed in SP1: - I am already running on the SP1
Release Candidate (see my point 2). Although I had already applied all
updates/hotfixes which seemed possibly-relevant, I upgraded to the SP1 RC,
firstly in case I'd missed some, and secondly so that they were all tested as
a coherent whole.
2. Yet the problem persists !
3. As the final SP1 is to be released in some 2-6 weeks, I can only HOPE
that this issue will be resolved in time.
4. Your comment re preventing the computer from sleeping is noted, and I had
already created such a Power plan to facilitate unattended Windows Update,
One-Care Safety Scanner (sleep does not occur until the scan is complete, but
the results and subsequent actions are then unavailable as the wireless
network connection is lost during sleep, thus necessitating a lengthy
re-scan), backups etc.
5. However, leaving a computer running 24 hours/day as a workaround to
losing a wireless network connection during sleep is hardly professional -
especially as Microsoft actively promotes SLEEP with all it's inherent
advantages as it's recommended state in which to leave an unattended computer
at "power-off" !
6. I have been considering purchase of the new MICROSOFT WINDOWS HOME SERVER
which seems an excellent product to satisfy many of my system requirements.
Such purchase is however quite pointless unless this sleep/wireless issue is
first resolved.
7. I have always liked Microsoft products despite the many criticisms from
others over the years, I like Vista, and I welcome the increased stability of
SP1 (RC). As such a fan, I have 2 recommendations for Microsoft:
- Don't further delay the final release of SP1, DO try to include
resolutions to outstanding issues, BUT NOT at the expense of thorough
testing. The increased stability & performance of the SP1 RC is welcome.
- Perhaps more importantly, resolve SLEEP NETWORK issues once and for all -
even if it requires a fundamental re-think, and issue an SP2 resolving such
issues ASAP.
8. FINAL COMMENT TO MICROSOFT:
- SLEEP functionality is fundamental to VISTA.
- NETWORK functionality is fundamental to WINDOWS HOME SERVER.
- Most networked HOME USERS have a WIRELESS network.
- The success of VISTA/HOME SERVER thus depends upon resolving this issue.
- Contemplate the consequences of NOT resolving this issue.
--
Vultch
"skirwin" wrote:
>
>
> "Vulture" wrote:
>
> > 1. My network has ALWAYS failed upon RESUME FROM SLEEP using a WIRELESS
> > connection via a NETGEAR WN121T wireless-N USB 2.0 adapter, but NOT when
> > using a wired Ethernet connection.
> > 2. It also works perfectly from BOOT via the WN121T wireless connection with
> > my NETGEAR DG834N draft 802.11n (and another 802.11g) wireless modem/router
> > on Windows Vista Ultimate, both with and without the SP1 Release Candidate.
> > 3. But upon resumption from SLEEP, the wireless n/w connection has ALWAYS
> > failed: attempting to re-connect to the network fails, and Device Manager
> > reports for the WN121T that “Windows has stopped this device because it has
> > reported problems (code 43)”.
> > 4. The only remedy is to REBOOT.
> > 5. The consequences of this are twofold:
> > - firstly, Microsoft-recommended sleep mode is consequently irrelevant
> > as a
> > reboot is necessary anyway to re-establish the wireless connection,
> > - secondly, as no wireless connection appears to be maintained during
> > sleep,
> > Windows Update, backup and other important maintenance via n/w cannot be
> > scheduled during sleep.
> > 6. The RELEVANT Vista system settings & status are:
> > - ReadyBoost: active with 1860MB
> > - WN121T power setting: “Allow the computer to turn off this device
> > to save
> > power” is unchecked (i.e. blank)
> > - Power plan:
> > - wireless adapter: “maximum performance”
> > - allow hybrid sleep: “on”
> > - hibernate: “never”
> > - WN121T Drivers: always latest (fails with both Microsoft
> > & NETGEAR).
> > 7. (NON-RELEVANT factors would appear to include that the motherboard has no
> > disks directly attached (the 1TB of RAID10 disk storage is provided via an
> > OEM h/w upgrade to an LSI 8308ELP MegaRAID board), as the failure also
> > occurred prior to this upgrade – albeit prior to SP1 and with the drivers
> > then available in July 2007.)
> > 8. It seems clear that this issue is either a GENERAL FAILURE IN MICROSOFT
> > SLEEP FUNCTIONALITY FOR USB 2.0 WIRELESS NETWORKS, or a SPECIFIC ISSUE IN THE
> > NETGEAR WN121T DRIVER NOT ACCOMMODATING THE MICROSOFT SLEEP FUNCTIONALITY.
> > Either way, it would seem a NETGEAR DRIVER v MICROSOFT SLEEP issue.
> > 9. This issue has been repeatedly reported to Microsoft for some 6 months
> > via Problems & Solutions and more recently via the SP1 Release Candidate
> > reporting facility, without resolution.
> > 10. CAN YOU HELP?
> > - Have you experienced ANY wireless adapter failures ONLY AFTER
> > SLEEP on
> > VISTA (regardless of adapter)?
> > - Have you experienced ANY NETGEAR WN121T wireless adapter failures
> > ONLY AFTER SLEEP on VISTA?
> > - If so, have you reported them, to whom & with what response?
> > - Do you know of any remedies?
> > --
> > Vultch >
> Many vista user have been experiening promblems with just more than wirless
> adapters when resuming from sleep. Microsoft really messed up with the
> hibernation part of vista, but they are supposed to fix it with service pack
> 1. If you dont mind leaving your pc running I would recommend that you turn
> of sleep on your computer, that is if it is a desktop, until SP1 comes out. I
> to have had problem with USB flash drive, my Motorola wireless adapter, my
> printer and so on when resuming from sleep so i just turned it off and life
> has been much easier.