Windows Vista Forums

Which machine responds to a ping?

  1. #1


    jim-g Guest

    Which machine responds to a ping?

    Would you help straighten out my thinking on my LAN setup as to what device
    should respond to a ping plus what IP it would be providing?

    I was pinged by three machines in about 45 seconds last night in this
    configuration so I'm trying to figure out what is going on. My setup is:

    Motorola Cable Modem followed by a Netgear WRN2000 'n' router (firewall
    setup) then two machines with only one active at the time of the incident.

    Sensing some attempts to gain access to my setup, I added Comodo Firewall
    (only) to the laptop in case someone was getting past the router firewall.
    Last night Comodo, in a 45 second span, asked to approve, or not, a response
    to pinging, then another unit with one number higher in his IP then it
    changed to a third ping and it was one number higher.

    Since the router has a firewall, my assumption was that the router would
    respond to the ping with the WAN-IP assigned by the cable company. (router
    log showed nothing regarding the incident)

    If that is wrong and the router passes the ping through to my laptop, what
    IP WAN or LAN is the response to the outsider?

    Either my assumption is wrong or someone is really good at getting through.

    What should be happening here? Thanks, Jim


      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #2


    jim-g Guest

    Re: Which machine responds to a ping?


    Forgot to mention this is Vista Ultimate on this system.

    "jim-g" <##jimg@xxxxxx> wrote in message
    news:O0yY1cDxJHA.1212@xxxxxx

    > Would you help straighten out my thinking on my LAN setup as to what
    > device should respond to a ping plus what IP it would be providing?
    >
    > I was pinged by three machines in about 45 seconds last night in this
    > configuration so I'm trying to figure out what is going on. My setup is:
    >
    > Motorola Cable Modem followed by a Netgear WRN2000 'n' router (firewall
    > setup) then two machines with only one active at the time of the incident.
    >
    > Sensing some attempts to gain access to my setup, I added Comodo Firewall
    > (only) to the laptop in case someone was getting past the router firewall.
    > Last night Comodo, in a 45 second span, asked to approve, or not, a
    > response to pinging, then another unit with one number higher in his IP
    > then it changed to a third ping and it was one number higher.
    >
    > Since the router has a firewall, my assumption was that the router would
    > respond to the ping with the WAN-IP assigned by the cable company.
    > (router log showed nothing regarding the incident)
    >
    > If that is wrong and the router passes the ping through to my laptop, what
    > IP WAN or LAN is the response to the outsider?
    >
    > Either my assumption is wrong or someone is really good at getting
    > through.
    >
    > What should be happening here? Thanks, Jim

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #3


    Jack-MVP Guest

    Re: Which machine responds to a ping?

    Hi
    If you would look at the Router's log you would see constant Pinging from
    the Internet on the WAN Port.
    This is a normal "noise at the gate" of the Router and it is very common in
    Cable Internet connection.
    You have to make sure that the Router is set to discard this Pings, and they
    would Not enter to your system.
    Look at the Router's manual for how-to.
    If it is keeping coming run this free util on each computer to find the
    source of the traffic.
    http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/s.../bb897437.aspx
    Jack (MS, MVP-Networking)

    "jim-g" <##jimg@xxxxxx> wrote in message
    news:O0yY1cDxJHA.1212@xxxxxx

    > Would you help straighten out my thinking on my LAN setup as to what
    > device should respond to a ping plus what IP it would be providing?
    >
    > I was pinged by three machines in about 45 seconds last night in this
    > configuration so I'm trying to figure out what is going on. My setup is:
    >
    > Motorola Cable Modem followed by a Netgear WRN2000 'n' router (firewall
    > setup) then two machines with only one active at the time of the incident.
    >
    > Sensing some attempts to gain access to my setup, I added Comodo Firewall
    > (only) to the laptop in case someone was getting past the router firewall.
    > Last night Comodo, in a 45 second span, asked to approve, or not, a
    > response to pinging, then another unit with one number higher in his IP
    > then it changed to a third ping and it was one number higher.
    >
    > Since the router has a firewall, my assumption was that the router would
    > respond to the ping with the WAN-IP assigned by the cable company.
    > (router log showed nothing regarding the incident)
    >
    > If that is wrong and the router passes the ping through to my laptop, what
    > IP WAN or LAN is the response to the outsider?
    >
    > Either my assumption is wrong or someone is really good at getting
    > through.
    >
    > What should be happening here? Thanks, Jim

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #4


    jim-g Guest

    Re: Which machine responds to a ping?

    Thanks Jack, This has been a good re-learning experience for an old timer
    who has been away from networking for a long time. Finally was able to
    work back to find out the Toshiba laptop was 'calling for updates'.


      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #5


    Bill Kearney Guest

    Re: Which machine responds to a ping?


    You can also check the ARP table on the receiving machine. The command to
    use is 'arp -a' from the cmd shell.

    That will show you the hardware MAC address, mapped to the IP address, of
    anything that's tried to connect to it. You could then compare that MAC
    info to your other devices on your network. An 'ipconfig /all' cmd on a PC
    will tell you it's MAC address. Other equipment like printers or routers
    will often have that on a serial number label. The info may shed additional
    light on what's connected to your network.

    Your question would probably be better asked on a forum for that netgear
    equipment.


    "jim-g" <##jimg@xxxxxx> wrote in message
    news:O0yY1cDxJHA.1212@xxxxxx

    > Would you help straighten out my thinking on my LAN setup as to what
    > device should respond to a ping plus what IP it would be providing?
    >
    > I was pinged by three machines in about 45 seconds last night in this
    > configuration so I'm trying to figure out what is going on. My setup is:
    >
    > Motorola Cable Modem followed by a Netgear WRN2000 'n' router (firewall
    > setup) then two machines with only one active at the time of the incident.
    >
    > Sensing some attempts to gain access to my setup, I added Comodo Firewall
    > (only) to the laptop in case someone was getting past the router firewall.
    > Last night Comodo, in a 45 second span, asked to approve, or not, a
    > response to pinging, then another unit with one number higher in his IP
    > then it changed to a third ping and it was one number higher.
    >
    > Since the router has a firewall, my assumption was that the router would
    > respond to the ping with the WAN-IP assigned by the cable company.
    > (router log showed nothing regarding the incident)
    >
    > If that is wrong and the router passes the ping through to my laptop, what
    > IP WAN or LAN is the response to the outsider?
    >
    > Either my assumption is wrong or someone is really good at getting
    > through.
    >
    > What should be happening here? Thanks, Jim

      My System SpecsSystem Spec


Which machine responds to a ping?
Similar Threads
Thread Forum
Cannot Ping XP Machine Vista networking & sharing
Did vista change the way ping responds? Vista networking & sharing
Cannot even Ping my own machine. Vista networking & sharing
Can't ping Vista machine from XP machine? Vista networking & sharing
Cannot Ping XP-Pro machine Vista networking & sharing