Firewall in Vista beta2 doesn't prompt you for outgoing connection

type "firewall" in the search box and you can configure Windows Firewall in
order to block outgoing connections or to create advanced rules. But why
there's not an option in order to get a prompt for outgoing connections? Why
is it not possible to cleate a rule on the fly with a dialog box that shows
that a particular program wants to estabilish a connection right now? It's
very difficult configure a program if you don't know it wants estabilish an
outgoing connection! I hope in RC1 it will be improved.

I fully agree with your assessment and your view on the need for this
ability. I certainly hope they do not plan on leaving it as is. I would not
have any need for Vista then.

I can't even get IE to work though with rules by app path or destination
port! Anyone else get outbound firewalling working?

If so, a script to set some basic stuff would be nice. I presume either a
vbscript or a bat can do any netsh commands for this (if its ready).

"BillD" wrote:

> type "firewall" in the search box and you can configure Windows Firewall in
> order to block outgoing connections or to create advanced rules. But why
> there's not an option in order to get a prompt for outgoing connections? Why
> is it not possible to cleate a rule on the fly with a dialog box that shows
> that a particular program wants to estabilish a connection right now? It's
> very difficult configure a program if you don't know it wants estabilish an
> outgoing connection! I hope in RC1 it will be improved.

I fully agree with your assessment and your view on the need for this
ability. I certainly hope they do not plan on leaving it as is. I would not
have any need for Vista then.

I can't even get IE to work though with rules by app path or destination
port! Anyone else get outbound firewalling working?

If so, a script to set some basic stuff would be nice. I presume either a
vbscript or a bat can do any netsh commands for this (if its ready).

"BillD" wrote:

> type "firewall" in the search box and you can configure Windows Firewall in
> order to block outgoing connections or to create advanced rules. But why
> there's not an option in order to get a prompt for outgoing connections? Why
> is it not possible to cleate a rule on the fly with a dialog box that shows
> that a particular program wants to estabilish a connection right now? It's
> very difficult configure a program if you don't know it wants estabilish an
> outgoing connection! I hope in RC1 it will be improved.

Sorry for the dub post. Thats IE7 on Vista for you. Flashing like crazy and
then telling me my post failed to process...but still processing it...yet not
displaying it....on a Microsoft support site! oi!


"ydks" wrote:

> I fully agree with your assessment and your view on the need for this
> ability. I certainly hope they do not plan on leaving it as is. I would not
> have any need for Vista then.
>
> I can't even get IE to work though with rules by app path or destination
> port! Anyone else get outbound firewalling working?
>
> If so, a script to set some basic stuff would be nice. I presume either a
> vbscript or a bat can do any netsh commands for this (if its ready).
>
> "BillD" wrote:
>
> > type "firewall" in the search box and you can configure Windows Firewall in
> > order to block outgoing connections or to create advanced rules. But why
> > there's not an option in order to get a prompt for outgoing connections? Why
> > is it not possible to cleate a rule on the fly with a dialog box that shows
> > that a particular program wants to estabilish a connection right now? It's
> > very difficult configure a program if you don't know it wants estabilish an
> > outgoing connection! I hope in RC1 it will be improved.