Windows Vista Forums

why updates?
  1. #1



    Newbie
    Join Date : Feb 2010
    Posts : 7
    Windows Vista Home Premium 32bit
    Local Time: 03:32 PM

    why updates?

    I looked at my recent updates and was astonished that there are 96 of them.
    It seems to me that software that has 96 problems shouldn't be available for sale.
    Each time I download a new update my system gets a little more crappy.



    Its a lot like selling you a junk car that doesnt work and then giving you the parts one at a time to try and get it running properly.

    Can anyone give me a good reason why all the updates/repairs?
    Why dont they get it right BEFORE they sell it?

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  2. #2
    Kari's Avatar

    Virtual Vista User
    Join Date : Mar 2010
    A Finnish immigrant in Leipzig, Germany
    Posts : 20
    Seven Ultimate x64, Virtual Vista Ultimate x86
    Local Time: 09:32 PM
    finland de saxony

     

    Re: why updates?

    Software development is a continuous process of development and innovation. Especially so with operating systems. 96 updates does not mean 96 faults, it means the technology and knowledge are developing, too, and Microsoft Windows has to meet the challenge.

    Quote Originally Posted by Grimes View Post
    Its a lot like selling you a junk car that doesnt work and then giving you the parts one at a time to try and get it running properly.

    Can anyone give me a good reason why all the updates/repairs?
    Why dont they get it right BEFORE they sell it?
    The question above is about the same than asking why didn't they make Windows ready when Windows 1.0 was released on November 1985? Why do they update it now, every time when new technological innovations make a new feature possible and available, or when user reports show that users want a change in an old feature? Why these major updates called versions, why Win98, XP, 7? Why wasn't Windows ready when released in 1985?

    Or your car metaphor: Why do they update the cars? Why do they put these new things like GPS and ABS and so on to the cars? Why should I update my car by changing the tires, why can't I always drive with tires I got when I bought the car? Why do I have to update my car by buying fuel, why can't I drive with the fuel I had when I bought the car?

    Personally, I'm happy Microsoft thinks my needs and gives an update to my system for instance when it's clear some cracker has found a way to exploit it. With an update I can close the lid, make it impossible to use that crack.

    Only a couple of days ago we had a good example about Microsoft listening consumer needs. Because virtualization technology is not possible in some PC's, Microsoft changed its former policy and published an update that makes it possible to use Virtual PC and XP Mode in every computer running Seven Professional or Ultimate. Also those with no VT. It's a major change, made possible through update system.

    Kari

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  3. #3
    whs's Avatar

    Senior Member



    Join Date : May 2008
    Germany/Florida
    Posts : 1,982
    Vista home premium 32bit
    Local Time: 10:32 PM
    germany us florida

     

    Re: why updates?

    Quote Originally Posted by Grimes View Post
    I looked at my recent updates and was astonished that there are 96 of them.
    It seems to me that software that has 96 problems shouldn't be available for sale.
    Each time I download a new update my system gets a little more crappy.

    Its a lot like selling you a junk car that doesnt work and then giving you the parts one at a time to try and get it running properly.

    Can anyone give me a good reason why all the updates/repairs?
    Why dont they get it right BEFORE they sell it?
    96 updates is only the tip of the iceberg. A commonly used number in the industry is that there is 1 problem per every 1000 lines of code. And Vista is about 55 million lines of code - you make the math.
    The good news is that the average user will never hit most of those problems because he uses only a very small subset of the operating system.
    If you were able to show how "to get it right" the first time around, you would probably win a Nobel prize. After 35 years in operating system development, I do not have the faintest idea how that could be done.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  4. #4



    Newbie
    Join Date : Feb 2010
    Posts : 7
    Windows Vista Home Premium 32bit
    Local Time: 03:32 PM


      Thread Starter

    Re: why updates?

    Apparently these updates are not what they were meant to be or we wouldnt have hundreds of forums like this one full of people having problems "buying gas for their computers"
    When the solution is worse than the problem you need to start over.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  5. #5
    Kari's Avatar

    Virtual Vista User
    Join Date : Mar 2010
    A Finnish immigrant in Leipzig, Germany
    Posts : 20
    Seven Ultimate x64, Virtual Vista Ultimate x86
    Local Time: 09:32 PM
    finland de saxony

     

    Re: why updates?

    Have you really read these forums, with thought? The issues and problems are mostly caused by user, third party hardware or software, overclocking and tweaking, false beliefs and expectations and so on. And don't forget third party driver problems, which has nothing to do with Windows.

    There are remarkable few threads for instance here and The Seven Forums where culprit, the guilty part, really is Windows. And quite a many Windows updates are drivers for third party devices.

    Computing would be easier and the we would need less updates and versions, if we all had exactly the same hardware and software. As you know, that's never going to happen.

    Kari

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  6. #6



    Newbie
    Join Date : Feb 2010
    Posts : 7
    Windows Vista Home Premium 32bit
    Local Time: 03:32 PM


      Thread Starter

    Re: why updates?

    I can relate to what you are saying and I am glad microsoft offers new features on occasion.

    However a new feature is not repairing something that never worked right. A new feature is for example being able to plug it directly into your tv and using your tv for a monitor.
    To use the car metaphor,
    buying gas/tires is maintenance. rebuilding a carburetor that NEVER worked right is a fix. A new stereo system/GPS is a new feature.
    I dont mind selling a car that needs gas. I do mind selling a car that doesnt start or dies at every stop light.

    Here are some more thoughts on "updates" right at the bottom of this page.
    "Vista Updates not displayed in Installed Updates"
    "How to remove the updates from 'uninstall updates"
    "Windows Updates, and now other updates fail consistently"
    These people will be glad there is nothing wrong with their computer and it is only a "new feature"

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  7. #7
    whs's Avatar

    Senior Member



    Join Date : May 2008
    Germany/Florida
    Posts : 1,982
    Vista home premium 32bit
    Local Time: 10:32 PM
    germany us florida

     

    Re: why updates?

    But Grimes, nobody is being forced to install updates. That may be a little iffy when it comes to security updates. But you can go by the saying: "If it ain't broke, don't fix it".
    On one of my Vista systems I have chosen not to install SP2 because it gave me problems on another system. However, on a third system, SP2 works fine. Go figure.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  8. #8
    Kari's Avatar

    Virtual Vista User
    Join Date : Mar 2010
    A Finnish immigrant in Leipzig, Germany
    Posts : 20
    Seven Ultimate x64, Virtual Vista Ultimate x86
    Local Time: 09:32 PM
    finland de saxony

     

    Re: why updates?

    Grimes, this is pointless.

    You have decided not to believe facts. You want to show how clever you are.

    It's OK. I can accept that. Your playground, your game.

    Next time you see me to join a conversation with you is when you first show me you are an adult.

    I have no time to play with kids.

    Unsubscribing, Kari

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  9. #9
    theog's Avatar

    Senior Member


    Join Date : Aug 2009
    uk Hampshire
    Posts : 640
    vista home premium 32bit
    Local Time: 09:32 PM
    uk

     

    Re: why updates?

    Well said, Kari.

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

  10. #10
    MWRed's Avatar

    I'd rather be fishin

    Join Date : Apr 2009
    Evansville, Wisconsin,U.S.
    Posts : 1,130
    Vista Home Premium 32bit
    Local Time: 02:32 PM
    usa us wisconsin

     

    Re: why updates?

    Three things come to my mind:

    1. All hardware is different, and how can an OS be "ready" for processors, video cards, ram, when it hasn't even been produced at the time of the OS's conception.

    2. Software changes daily, if not more often.

    3. People don't think before they do something.
    Sure, if you install windows, and don't connect to the internet, or install anything, it would be just fine, although pointless. A paperweight with wallpaper.

    Side note, not all updates are "problems". Some are improvements, some are compatibility, and some are not needed by all ( a la .NET).



    Here are some more thoughts on "updates" right at the bottom of this page.
    "Vista Updates not displayed in Installed Updates"
    "How to remove the updates from 'uninstall updates"
    "Windows Updates, and now other updates fail consistently"
    These people will be glad there is nothing wrong with their computer and it is only a "new feature"
    The main point here is "their computer"....not "every computer with this OS".
    If USER1 has a problem, and USERS 2,3,4,and 5 don't.........is it the OS's fault that USER1 has an issue? No.

    there's a never ending cycle of software and hardware technology, it is not POSSIBLE to keep ahead of it.
    If ya want it perfect before it's released....gimme a call around the year 2150 and let me know how Windows 8 is coming along......

      My System SpecsSystem Spec

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
why updates? problems?

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Vista Updates not displayed in Installed Updates davisj01 Windows Updates 10 31 Mar 2010
Export Installed updates(windows updates) Export Add Remove Program Lists Vista General 4 15 Jun 2009
How to remove the updates from 'uninstall updates' Magic531 Windows Updates 4 22 Apr 2009
Windows Updates, and now other updates fail consistently mobiledog Windows Updates 25 18 Aug 2008
HELP! Can't change Automatic Updates or check for updates! VKGT Vista performance & maintenance 1 05 Jul 2008