There is no guarantee that it would work with either disc, although it should. Dont make me swear to this, but it is my understanding that all Vista CDs are the same, if from MS. Its the key that determines what system you put on your computer.
The HP DVD is probably an OEM and you cannot use that for your repair, in many cases. In addition the OEM is only one Edition and not all, like I mentioned above.
You may want to open a new user account and see if Event Viewer works in that account.
You may have disabled Event Viewer to turn it on
STEP 1>Open services.msc
STEP 2>Enable the following two services:-
SERVICE 1> WINDOWS EVENT LOG.
SERVICE 2> WINDOWS EVENT COLLECTOR.
STEP 3> Restart the computer, you are done